This month sees the release by Magnoli Clothiers of a third, and improved version of their Swirly tie - a replica of Tie Four (the Christian Lacroix).Here is my review
Aside from trawling eBay for the occasional hotly fought as-worn ties; or finding something that is evocative or similar to the tie you are looking for, there is another option – a rewoven copy by online costume maker Magnoli Clothiers.
Over the past four or so years Magnoli has produced copies of Tie Two (Daniel Hechter); Tie Four (Christian Lacroix) Tie Seven (Giorgio Armani); and Tie Ten (St George by Duffer).
It has taken several drafts to get the ties to something near screen-accurate.
The earliest version of Tie Two (Daniel Hechter) was printed, and though was replaced with a woven version the pattern was not changed. The latest incarnation is to a better pattern, but is not quite the right colours.
Tie Four (Christian Lacroix) has gone through two drafts to date, though the latter was a woven version of the appliquéd copy seen in The Eleventh Hour, so wasn’t quite right on several levels.
But this month has seen the release of further update to Tie Four, this time replicating its main original appearance in The Girl In The Fireplace (it did appear briefly in other episodes, but since Louise Page herself regards The Girl In The Fireplace as its main use, I see it as that too).
Since February this year, when I found my original colourway version of the Christian Lacroix tie, the pressure has been on to make a more faithful version.
The second draft Magnoli had improved the pattern, but it was out of scale with the real thing, something that was difficult to match without having an original in-hand to work to.
So, using the images from my posting a new version has been redrawn from scratch, correcting many of the errors in the pattern seen in the previous version.
The colour has also been improved, though I’m of the opinion it has gone a bit too far.
The red patches inside the swirls haven’t been changed much since the previous draft, so look lighter in contrast to the brown. They could have done with being darker, but aren’t so bad I guess.
The scale of the pattern has been improved, but comparing it again to my original, it is still somewhat larger. I don’t know if this is an error that has crept in during manufacture, as ties are cut on the bias so tend to stretch a little after production.
That said, at US$45 this IS the best replica Tie Four to date, so is well worth the money.
The dedicated cosplayers should grab one while you can!
This has always been my favorite Tennant Tie.ReplyDelete
It's great to see them all getting closer. I still have the printed first draft among my Magnoli ties of Tie Two somewhere, which is an interesting discussion piece what with it no longer being available.
I have to say however, that though I like the newer Tie Four, I will always prefer it without the red. The blue and brown looks so much nicer to me.
Totally agree with you!Delete
Would you say Magnoli's dark brown background or "black" (really dark background) of this tie is closest to the screen version?ReplyDelete
I'd say its the best so far, but from what I gather this tie us from a batch where the brown was way too dark and woven before it was picked up on.Delete
There are effectively seconds, with a proper weave on the cards.